Amy Hayes

Find a Home to Suit Your Lifestyle.

Your home value.

Welcome

Meet Amy Hayes

    To me, a home isn't just a property or a point on a map; it is where life truly unfolds. Growing up in Eastern Nassau County and currently living in Speonk, my love for Long Island's South Shore and East End runs deep. From morning walks on the smooth, white sands of Tiana Beach, to quiet dinners on the North Fork, with live local jazz at the Southold Social Club, this coastal lifestyle is something I live, breathe, and cherish every single day.
    Licensed since 2014, I initially stepped into real estate seeking a career with limitless potential that offered the flexibility our family needed while my husband served in the NYPD. What began as a goal to build a scalable business with unlimited growth potential, quickly became my true passion: helping everyday families, buyers and sellers lay down roots, build generational wealth and find that unmistakable feeling of belonging.
    My approach is rooted in the deep local knowledge, authentic advocacy, and unwavering readiness to immerse myself in the work, providing hands-on leadership for my clients. Having worked directly in Southampton's records management, I bring a rare insider's understanding of town codes, house plans, property surveys, and permitting processes--saving my clients valuable time and eliminating unwanted surprises. Paired with my background in luxury cosmetic sales, I offer an innate eye for style, visual layout, and presentation to ensure every listing shines.
     Whether navigating Westhampton Beach and the surround on the South Shore, serving Suffolk County, or guiding clients across Nassau, I leverage cutting edge innovation, fierce negotiation, and a personal touch. Harnessing advanced tools for streamline and efficiency, saving my clients time and money. From year-round homes and seasonal retreats to land acquisitions, I am always reachable, always responsive, and entirely committed to turning your real estate goals into reality.

Amy Hayes Photo
217 Middle Country Road
Representing the Finest Properties

Featured Listings

$599,000
217 Middle Country Road, Middle Island, NY
Read More
89 Village Circle W
Representing the Finest Properties

Featured Listings

$79,000
89 Village Circle W, Manorville, NY
1 Bedrooms / 1 Bathrooms / 812 sqft
Read More
874 Birchwood Park Drive
Representing the Finest Properties

Featured Listings

$389,900
874 Birchwood Park Drive, Middle Island, NY
2 Bedrooms / 1 Bathrooms / 1,100 sqft
Read More
15 Glen Drive
Representing the Finest Properties

Featured Listings

$569,900
15 Glen Drive, Ridge, NY
2 Bedrooms / 2 Bathrooms / 1,476 sqft
Read More
1500 Main Street
Representing the Finest Properties

Featured Listings

$925,000
1500 Main Street, Port Jefferson, NY
Read More
379C Woodbridge Drive
Representing the Finest Properties

Featured Listings

$459,900
379C Woodbridge Drive, Ridge, NY
2 Bedrooms / 2 Bathrooms / 1,168 sqft
Read More

Sharing Experiences

What My Clients Are Saying

"Jesse and I appreciate all your hard work and patience during our buying process. Thank you for everything!"

- Lee & Jesse

"22 Berkshire Road Bethpage, NY 11714 Amy did an excellent job in presenting our home for the open house and positively promoting it. It was sold in one day! She is a very friendly and proactive person."

- Mr.& Mrs. Joseph M.

"Amy was consistently professional, Very prompt with paperwork and scheduling clients. Understood our needs and wishes. A pleasure to work with. "

- Jacqueline Esp – Seller

"Thank you so much Amy! You're incredible agent and person and I'm so happy we found you! You made our new journey nothing but ease and happiness. Thank you so much for all your hard work and kind motivating words"

- Christina Desantis – Buyer

Helping you to capitalize on current market opportunities and assist you in making the right choices.

Looking to Buy or Sell a Home?

Helping you to capitalize on current market opportunities and assist you in making the right choices.

I deliver extraordinary service by always giving you what you expect and deserve from me.

Home Sellers

Get the most value for your home.

Home Buyers

Find your perfect home now.

Top Stories

Fall Festival at Station Yards Ronkonkoma 2026 Photo

Fall Festival at Station Yards Ronkonkoma 2026

Third Annual Fall Fest at Station Yards in Ronkonkoma Autumn festivities return to central Long Island with a lively neighborhood block party. The Third Annual Fall Fest at ...

Read More
North Shore Kiwanis Dog Show 2026 Photo

North Shore Kiwanis Dog Show 2026

Official promotional flyer for the Kiwanis Dog Show at Garvies Point Road Dog Park. Kiwanis Dog Show 2026: North Shore Community Gathering Local dog lovers can bring their pets ...

Read More
Third-Generation Real Estate, Levittown History, and Community Impact: Tom Nails on 25 Years as Photo

Third-Generation Real Estate, Levittown History, and Community Impact: Tom Nails on 25 Years as

In Season 4, Episode 4 of the Work Hard, Play Hard & Give Back podcast, host Mike Litzner sits down with top-producing agent Tom Nails from the Coldwell Banker American Homes ...

Read More
Ronkonkoma Pet Adoption Event 2026 Photo

Ronkonkoma Pet Adoption Event 2026

Giving Back With Every Wag: Ronkonkoma Pet Adoption Drive Local community members on Saturday, October 10, 2026, at 12:00 PM have a great opportunity to welcome a new rescue pet ...

Read More

Amy Hayes specializes in market knowledge.

Working with me means more than finding an agent. I am dedicated to understanding your needs and guiding you through the real estate process with confidence. Your journey starts with a simple conversation.

Login to My Homefinder

TRANSIT SEARCH