Amy Hayes

Find a Home to Suit Your Lifestyle.

Your home value.

Welcome

Meet Amy Hayes

Expertise, Empathy, and Results Across Long Island

Real estate is never just a transaction—it is a major life transition. Since 2014, I have been guiding clients across Long Island with a simple philosophy:
listen first, lead second. From first-time homebuyers to luxury waterfront sellers across and beyond, I provide a seamless, stress-free experience tailored entirely to your unique goals.

The Advantage: Sharp Precision & Calm Execution

Success in real estate is found in the details. Navigating the fast-paced, high-stakes schedule of an NYPD family taught me how to be hyper-vigilant, highly organized, and exceptionally calm under pressure. Whether handling a complex contract or coordinating a tight timeline, I specialize in finding solutions where others see dead ends. You get a fierce advocate who protects your investment and ensures no detail is overlooked.

A Neighbor’s Perspective

My roots in the community run deep. Whether supporting local youth leadership through scouting or investing in cultural landmarks like The Gateway School of Performing Arts, I live and breathe the Long Island lifestyle. I combine deep local market knowledge with genuine empathy to ensure you feel heard, respected, and completely supported from our first meeting to the closing table.

Credentials & Community

    Member - Long Island Board of Realtors
New York Association of Realtors
National Association of Realtors
Military Relocation Professional Certification
Contributor- The Gateway School of Performing Arts in Bellport NY
Participant - Troop 94 Wading River NY


Amy Hayes Photo
20 Camp Drive
Representing the Finest Properties

Featured Listings

$799,990
20 Camp Drive, Selden, NY
6 Bedrooms / 3.5+ Bathrooms / 2,685 sqft
Read More
219 Artist Lake Drive
Representing the Finest Properties

Featured Listings

$329,990
219 Artist Lake Drive, Middle Island, NY
2 Bedrooms / 2 Bathrooms / 1,100 sqft
Read More
89 Village Circle W
Representing the Finest Properties

Featured Listings

$99,999
89 Village Circle W, Manorville, NY
1 Bedrooms / 1 Bathrooms / 812 sqft
Read More
222 Erik Drive
Representing the Finest Properties

Featured Listings

$649,900
222 Erik Drive, East Setauket, NY
2 Bedrooms / 2.5 Bathrooms / 1,700 sqft
Read More
135 Oakwood Road
Representing the Finest Properties

Featured Listings

$939,000
135 Oakwood Road, Port Jefferson, NY
4 Bedrooms / 3 Bathrooms / 2,400 sqft
Read More
61 Rocky Point Yaphank Road
Representing the Finest Properties

Featured Listings

$275,000
61 Rocky Point Yaphank Road, Rocky Point, NY
2 Bedrooms / 1 Bathrooms / 800 sqft
Read More

Sharing Experiences

What My Clients Are Saying

"22 Berkshire Road Bethpage, NY 11714 Amy did an excellent job in presenting our home for the open house and positively promoting it. It was sold in one day! She is a very friendly and proactive person."

- Mr.& Mrs. Joseph M.

"Amy was consistently professional, Very prompt with paperwork and scheduling clients. Understood our needs and wishes. A pleasure to work with. "

- Jacqueline Esp – Seller

"Thank you so much Amy! You're incredible agent and person and I'm so happy we found you! You made our new journey nothing but ease and happiness. Thank you so much for all your hard work and kind motivating words"

- Christina Desantis – Buyer

Helping you to capitalize on current market opportunities and assist you in making the right choices.

Looking to Buy or Sell a Home?

Helping you to capitalize on current market opportunities and assist you in making the right choices.

I deliver extraordinary service by always giving you what you expect and deserve from me.

Home Sellers

Get the most value for your home.

Home Buyers

Find your perfect home now.

Top Stories

Coldwell Banker American Homes Expands South Shore Footprint with Acquisition of Long Beach's Verdeschi & Walsh Realty Photo

Coldwell Banker American Homes Expands South Shore Footprint with Acquisition of Long Beach's Verdeschi & Walsh Realty

LONG BEACH, NY — Expanding its commitment to Long Island's coastal communities, Coldwell Banker American Homes today announced the strategic acquisition of Verdeschi & Walsh Re ...

Read More
Cycling For A Cause At The Nassau Bicycle Challenge Photo

Cycling For A Cause At The Nassau Bicycle Challenge

Pedal For A Purpose With Our Syosset Team At The Historic Thirtieth Annual Nassau Bicycle Challenge The highly anticipated 30th Annual Nassau Bicycle Challenge returns on June ...

Read More
Adopt Your Fur-Ever Best Friend at Coldwell Banker Mt. Sinai Photo

Adopt Your Fur-Ever Best Friend at Coldwell Banker Mt. Sinai

Come meet the Mt. Sinai puppies waiting to find their forever homes! A New Beginning: Adopt Your "Fur-Ever Best Friend" in Mt. Sinai The gentle rolling hills and coastal br ...

Read More

Heart of American Homes: How We Support Our New York Communities

Supporting Our Neighbors When It Matters Most Mike Litzer and I have been business partners for 38 years, and our commitment to the New York community has always been at the cor ...

Read More

Amy Hayes specializes in market knowledge.

Working with me means more than finding an agent. I am dedicated to understanding your needs and guiding you through the real estate process with confidence. Your journey starts with a simple conversation.

Login to My Homefinder

Pixel
TRANSIT SEARCH